Most Common Reasons for Rejection
Nobody likes rejection. If you’ve spent plenty of your time and energy on your latest paper, solely to possess it turned down, it’s about to hurt. Articles get rejected for all manner of reasons, from simple to avoid errors and oversights, to easily falling outside of the journal’s scope. during this two-part journal post (part two to follow next week) we’ll check out a number of the foremost common reasons for rejection in additional detail, before discussing the varied choices hospitable you if your article is rejected. So, what are the foremost probably reasons for rejection?
The manuscript fails the technical screening
Before the manuscript gets passed to the Editor-in-Chief or editor in chief of a journal, the editorial workplace can undertake some basic checks. the most reasons for rejection of papers at this stage include:
- The paper contains parts that are suspected to be plagiarised
- The paper is beneath review at another journal (submission to multiple journals at constant time isn’t allowed)
- The manuscript lacks key parts like a title, list of authors and affiliations, main text, references, or figures and tables
- The quality of the language isn’t comfortable for review to require place
- Tables and figures don’t seem to be clear enough to read
- The paper doesn’t change to the journal’s Author guidelines
The manuscript doesn’t fall at intervals the journal’s Aims and Scope
If the paper won’t be of interest or price to the journal’s audience, it’s unlikely to be accepted. once selecting a journal to suffer, continually make certain you scan the Aims and Scope thus you have got an understanding of the sort of articles the journal is trying to find.
The research topic isn’t of nice enough significance
Again, if the subject lined by the paper isn’t of interest to a journal’s audience, it’ll probably be rejected. it’s going to be that the paper’s findings area unit progressive and don’t advance the sphere, or that the manuscript is clearly a part of a bigger study that has been shared to form as several articles as doable.
The research is over-ambitious
If the authors are excessively bold or encompassing, results could also be tough to interpret or could even be blemished. In these cases it’s going to be additional applicable to divide the work into a series of smaller research comes.
A transparent hypothesis hasn’t been established
The question behind the research could also be unclear, poorly developed, or not relevant to the research field. concluding an intensive literature review will facilitate guide your hypothesis or research question.
The manuscript is incomplete
The paper would possibly contain observations however isn’t a full study, or it’s going to ignore or overlook alternative vital add the sphere.
There are flaws within the procedures, presentation or analysis of the information
Major flaws would possibly embrace an absence of clear management teams or alternative comparison metrics, non-conformity with recognized procedures or methodology (which makes it tough to repeat or replicate the work), or the dearth of a statistically valid analysis. be careful for any minor flaws like the wrong, inappropriate or unclear labelling of tables and figures.
Flaws within the manuscript’s arguments and/or conclusions
Arguments ought to be logical, structured and valid, and support the conclusions reached by the paper. If the conclusions reached can not be even on the idea of the remainder of the paper, or they ignore massive parts of the literature, the manuscript are rejected.
Language, writing and writing system problems
The language, structure of the paper, and any tables or figures got to be of fine enough quality for the paper to be assessed; if this isn’t doable, then the paper are rejected. It’s continually an honest plan to raise others to envision your paper before you submit it — a second combine of eyes will facilitate obtain any errors you may have lost. If you aren’t assured in your English writing skills, most publishers supply English language editing services that you’ll use before submitting your paper.